[Gut Pile]

Why do the Amish hunt public land ? I thought that they all owned farms or something along that line.

I seen more Amish hunters on public land than I have pine trees the past 5 years.

This is perplexing to me, can someone educate me on this.:bonk:

 

[scott trout]

Iv always wondered why myself I think it might be just to go to McDonalds.

 

[Wilber13]

Why do the Amish hunt public land ? I thought that they all owned farms or something along that line.

I seen more Amish hunters on public land than I have pine trees the past 5 years.

This is perplexing to me, can someone educate me on this.:bonk:

As far as I have seen and heard in my area is that they kill everything in there area!! Experience of mine if hunting around Amish property most all game was very scarce! That goes for the fishin holes!

Posted using Outdoor Hub Campfire

 

[Gut Pile]

I have heard that they are very unethical in regards to hunting.

 

[Edensjr]

Just seen where guy posted in another topic they took his deer while he was givin it time to expire.

 

[Wilber13]

I have heard that they are very unethical in regards to hunting.

Yeah my brother saw the game warden with some Amish men last year during gun season. Lets say they got in some trouble had six deer between two men on there buggy non where tagged and they where hunting public land. The game warden was loading there guns into there truck and another heaving the deer into the bed of there infamous green truck!!

Posted using Outdoor Hub Campfire

 

[MASHUNTER18]

Because they cut all the trees down on their land.....lol........


Same reason all the other drivers do, drive all the public land, and save theirs to hunt later.

 

[brtisbuck]

Unfortunately they are not (well many of them) too ethical, likely to follow the rules to the letter, and no fun to hunt near. I feel bad for those hunters who own adjoining property to them.

 

[antiqucycle]

Most of us have drivers licenses from the state we reside in. I wonder how many amish have non resident licenses. or simply resident licenses from several states, like Ohio, Pa, NY?

They do like to "can" venison.

 

[celloguy]

Well, for one, it is public land; second, having witnessed them hunting in the past they no longer have any game on their land; three, it is public land. If you see anyone breaking the law, call the law.

 

[scott trout]

Just seen where guy posted in another topic they took his deer while he was givin it time to expire.

That was me. I hit her she went down then got up and dragged herself a couple of feet then it looked Luke she went down again. She was ontop of a hill and I was at the bottom so my view was obstructed. I backed off for a bit to let her bleed out.20 min later they come marching to her she gets up and they blow her away.

 

[Edensjr]

They don't leave anything breathing in the woods huh?

 

[Gasfish26]

Do they even pay taxes to help secure the public hunting lands?

Posted using Outdoor Hub Campfire

 

[Lundy43123]

The only difference I can see in hunting styles and ethics between the ******** that hunt near me and the Amish is that they drive F150's instead of buggy's

 

[muzzy75]

Why do the Amish hunt public land ? I thought that they all owned farms or something along that line.

I seen more Amish hunters on public land than I have pine trees the past 5 years.

This is perplexing to me, can someone educate me on this.:bonk:

From my past observations they hunt anywhere they want.. I think they feel rules don't apply to them. I hunted a farm for years that was good hunting then the farms around it were slowly purchased by the Amish. Then the Deer and Turks got real thin to the point where I didn't hardly see anything anymore. Needless to say I don't hunt Holmes County anymore. :nono:

 

[coonskinner]

Blame the odnr...farmers ...coyotes ...gunners...drivers...meat hunters...ha ha ha...now its the Amish ...well at least the Amish know to adapt when theres no deer and go where they are ...and they have the right to be on public as much as yo:biggrin:u ...

 

[JBSedon]

The only difference I can see in hunting styles and ethics between the ******** that hunt near me and the Amish is that they drive F150's instead of buggy's

Yup.

Black Dog Bowfishing Pro Staff

 

[beck_trt]

The Amish own 240 acres along my south and east boundaries. They do not shoot small bucks and are very careful about the number of does they shoot (3 so far this year). Along my North border is a group of professional engineers who are in there late 50's. They are the biggest slobs I have ever witnessed. Watched one guy shoot at a deer 12 times this year, shooting from there property onto mine, claiming they were trying to turn the deer! 2 bullets were within 50 feet of me. I have never lost my cool the way I did on those guys.

If the opportunity ever presents itself, the Amish and I are going to buy out the engineers just to put a stop to the BS.

 

[REDARROW7]

Why do the Amish hunt public land ? I thought that they all owned farms or something along that line.

I seen more Amish hunters on public land than I have pine trees the past 5 years.

This is perplexing to me, can someone educate me on this.:bonk:

Because they kill everything off their land land,then move on to destroy what we try and manage somewhere else,hey does mike tonkavich wear a straw hat

 

[REDARROW7]

Blame the odnr...farmers ...coyotes ...gunners...drivers...meat hunters...ha ha ha...now its the Amish ...well at least the Amish know to adapt when theres no deer and go where they are ...and they have the right to be on public as much as yo:biggrin:u ...

You post the most meaningless comments on here,you are a funny little man!