hey BB
Im not against those who use UL rods for smallies..i just dont prefer them for my fishing, but again i dont fish from a Yak either were long rods could be a problem..
Only reason i bought both my boys UL rods is they are 7 & 8 yrs old and can not handle a longer rod.
I matched Tylers Fenwick with the same 5'3" HMX that Andy has, i put on a Shimano Sedona 500FA because it was the only small reel that didnt feel too heavy for that rod and he could reach the line with his finger .
He did awsome with it last year and was casting like a pro towards the end...he tok a 17" & 18.5" smallie on this set up using of course G-power 6lb line
I bought my youngest a 5' UL rod, but bought him an Okuma Avenger 15AV that has 6BB's and instant anti-reverse...i turned around and bought one for Tylers combo as it is SO much better than that Sedona.
I fish streams for smallies and have caught a 20'+ smallie each year for the last 7 yrs..i catch a ton of smallies 16"-19" every year also. Last year i got 300+ smallies fishing for them part-time along with all the other species i fsh for.
I personaly prefer LONGER rods than most with my shortest rods from 7' one pcs. in small streams all the way up to 8'6" 2 pcs. for certain baits ,of course there ALL St. Croixs

.
My favorite all around rod is a 7' one pcs Tidemaster Inshore rod rated med. power, fast action, 8-17lb line, 1/4-3/4oz.
I have take most of my big smallies on this rod.
Now i know the quaulity of fish that others hav in thier streams might not be like mine, but still i dont want to have a LARGE smallie on close to wood or rocks and loose it because i was using UL gear.
But rods and reels are a PERSONAL choice and you have to match them for the size of the fish YOU catch !