George,
There is no doubt that many of the deer on the property get harvested on the adjoing land. More than once I've watched as deer cross the fields and jump the fence only to be followed up by shots during the guns seasons. By the same token many of the deer on the adjoining lands end up on the land we hunt by midweek because of the hunting pressure on the lands around us. We hunt the edges and travel routes from the wooded sections on this property. More than 3/4 of the woods on this property never have a soul, including us, walk into them during the entire season. The deer become very comfortable with these various wooded areas and must feel pretty safe from the human element because they sure stack up in there during the deer gun seasons.
Can we control if a mature buck decides to cross the fences and get shot?, absolulty not, but we can sure pass on shooting him when he is young in hope he will grow to full maturity.
When we first started leasing this property 7 years ago the sighting of a decent buck was not all that common, today it is a every day occurance with sightings of numerous nice bucks and many times the same nice buck numerous times in the same day.
I will not sit in judgement of what a trophy buck is to anyone else. Each individual can and does set his or her own standards. To my family there is a minimum standard to what determines if a deer is a "shooter" or not. We do not lower that standard on the last days of the season just to harvest a buck. We take plenty of deer for the freezer every year, if a nice buck is included in that kill, great, if not we'll fill the freezer with does. This is what we enjoy as hunters. If a young buck jumps the fence and gets killed that's OK, it met the criteria of what that hunter was looking for, that's what it's all about. Each hunter deciding for themselves what they want out of hunting.
I also know that we make the hunting for older mature bucks better on the surrounding lands also. Many of these bucks get harvested on the adjoining farms, not as many as the young bucks, but some of the older ones do get harvested.
We choose to manage the deer on this property with the only means available to us. We choose not to shoot the younger bucks in hopes that some will survive to maturity. So far to date the results have been outstanding.
Kim